I remember the first time I met Dan Willingham. I had just joined the Core Knowledge Foundation and Dan, a board member and esteemed University of Virginia cognitive scientist, was giving a talk at the Education Trust conference in Washington, DC. As he ranged widely over the role of background knowledge, the limits of reading comprehension strategies instruction, critical thinking skills, and managing students’ attention, I literally bounced in my seat with excitement. “I knew it! I knew it!” I was thinking to myself. Fresh from five years of classroom teaching in a low-performing South Bronx public school, I had intuited many of the points Dan made in his talk. It was edifying to hear this heralded figure validating much of what I’d come to feel certain about in classroom teaching—much of it contrary to what my staff developers, ed school professors, and others insisted was “best practice.”
But let’s not bury the lede: While I was invigorated by Dan’s talk I should have been upset, even furious. Why had I been put in a position to have to grope and fumble my way toward effective practice? What price had been paid by my students, low-income Black and brown children living in the nation’s poorest Congressional district, for administrative hubris and oversight? Why had I been left to discover Willingham, E.D. Hirsch, Jr., and others on my own rather than in ed school or in professional development? Where was this wisdom and clarity when I needed it, when it might have benefitted my students who had so little margin for error in their education?
A friend and colleague, also a New York City school teacher, once described his ed school and teacher training in terms that mirrored mine precisely: “a mix of folk wisdom, psycho-jargon, wishful thinking, and out-and-out bullshit.” I still have the notes from my first week of training in New York City’s District 7 (South Bronx) when we covered learning styles, which we’ve known for decades is a neuromyth, but one to which a large majority of teachers still subscribe.
I drifted into my post-classroom role in education policy when the ed reform movement was at the peak of its power and prestige. Yet I routinely encountered among would-be reformers what can politely be described as indifference about classroom practice. “Curriculum is like mom and apple pie,” one philanthropist sniffed as though everyone agrees on that (they do not). “The only thing that matters is teacher quality (not what he or she teaches?)” insisted an arrogant policy wonk. I’ve told the story elsewhere of meeting Michelle Rhee when she was leaving Washington, DC schools to found and run Students First, a shift that implied winning a legislative seat is more important to student outcomes than curriculum, pedagogy, or classroom culture. When one high-profile education blogger asked why I wrote so often about classroom management, I wondered why he didn’t. Every teacher I knew was obsessed with it and understood that nothing good happens amid classroom chaos.
Similarly education researchers are mostly content to treat the classroom as a black box, measuring what goes in and comes out, or as if the salient variable is whether the school is a charter or traditional public school with little or no thought given to the school’s pedagogical model or curriculum. It didn’t take me long to understand that the theory of change that has undergirded the education policy movement for the last 30 years rests at least tacitly on a mistaken assumption: that teachers, administrators, and schools are well-trained, competent, and capable of raising student achievement, and that the role of public policy is to direct, incentivize, or threaten livelihoods in order to get them to perform properly. I’ve never questioned the earnestness of the education reform movement, but surely if we’re serious about raising student achievement–not by a little, but a lot–we ought to be at least as curious about instructional matters as we have been about structural ones.
This is not a new line of thought. Several years ago, during one of the movement’s periodic bouts of self-flagellation and navel gazing, I wrote that “if ed reform is to regain its momentum and moral authority–not merely a disruptive force, but a broad, effective, and enduring one–it must reinvent itself as a practice-focused movement.”
This Substack, then, is an effort to take my own advice.
The time is ripe. The idea that improving practice holds the key to improving student outcomes has been greeted more receptively in recent years. We are now several years into a “science of reading” moment driven largely by the work of Emily Hanford, who also taught ed reform’s accountability hawks a useful lesson by demonstrating that teachers were not indifferent sinners but sinned against by many of the same experts and gurus whose ideas and ideologies dominated my South Bronx elementary school 20 years ago.
Another patron saint of this endeavor is my friend Tom Bennett, the founder of ResearchEd, a grassroots, teacher-led movement aimed at improving the use of evidence and research in education. Bennett’s core message is that teachers deserve access to high-quality research and need the skills to evaluate and apply it effectively. Well-attended ResearchEd conferences all over the world validate his dream of an education sector where evidence, not fads, trends, or intuition, drives decisions and innovations. Most pertinently, Tom’s optimistic vision is not waiting around or hoping to persuade existing institutions and teacher training channels to change their ways. Indeed, it assumes their resistance, interprets it as damage, and routes around it.
It is too grandiose to think a Substack can change the direction of the ed reform movement, but for those who are inclined to come along for the ride, here are a few guiding principles for what I hope you will see and read here:
A bridge between practice, policy, and research. The goal is for teachers to become more informed consumers of research and to apply evidence-based methods in their teaching–and for policymakers to become more informed consumers of effective classroom practice to more successfully calibrate their work.
A supportive, but clear-eyed view of teaching and teachers. For years I’ve pointed out that nearly four million full-time classroom teachers are needed to staff the nation’s classrooms. It is not insulting to observe that a number that large means teaching is a job that must be doable at a satisfactory level by mere mortals, men and women of average sentience and abilities. Classroom saints and superstars are interesting and occasionally inspiring, but they are not proof points: If a program, pedagogy, or policy cannot be implemented with reasonable fidelity by the vast majority of the nation’s teachers, it is not a solution.
Recognition that education is the public’s business with many stakeholders. Teachers, no less than cops, firemen, and sanitation workers, do their jobs on the public’s dime. They—we—are public employees and state actors with enormous influence over a captive audience of other people’s children. We have no right to think we are somehow exempt from scrutiny.
Finally, you will never be asked to support this Substack with a paid subscription. My mortgage is paid off, I’ve written my last check for my kid’s college tuition, dog food is inexpensive, and I draw a generous paycheck from the American Enterprise Institute. The last thing I’m going to ask is for modestly paid teachers to fork over even five bucks a month. The Next 30 Years is and will always be free to read and share.
Hopefully you’ll find it worth doing both.



Robert, this is a really terrific idea. And I love the core message.
Welcome to Substack, friend, can't wait to read it. Maybe there's a collab in our future!